The Humanity of Human Rights

Human rights have a bad rap, at least in certain circles. They are criticised for perniciously affecting law and order, hindering the UK’s attempts to control its borders and generally benefitting the unworthy. A notable example, that occurred in the course of the UK Parliament bringing human rights into domestic law for the first time, was Lord McCluskey who suggested that incorporation of the European Convention on Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms 1950 (the Convention) into UK law, following the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, would lead to “a field day for crackpots, a pain in the neck for judges and legislators, and a goldmine for lawyers”. In a similar vein, is a former UK Prime Minister who said that allowing prisoner voting in the country, on the basis of article 3 of Protocol 1 of the Convention, made him ‘physically ill’.

More recently, hostility has been expressed about the role which human rights have played in affecting the plan to summarily remove those arriving in ‘small boats’ to Rwanda. It is very common also to see headlines in the popular press including ‘European human rights laws pose a ‘real moral hazard to democracy’, James Cleverly says’, and ‘Human Rights farce that imperils us all’. Evidence of antipathy to human rights is not hard to find.

Evidence of human rights operating in a humane manner is less evident. Hence this blog post. One example of the humanity of human rights is found in a Scottish extradition case reported in 2020, DV v Lord Advocate, [2020] HCJAC 33. It is worth describing this in some detail because it illustrates the ultimate humanity of human rights, and at the same time demonstrates their rightful limits and the opposing interests that they may inimically affect.

Case Overview

The case arose from a Romanian extradition request to Scotland seeking a Romanian national, DV, to serve a prison sentence of 13 months for aggravated theft. DV opposed her extradition on the basis of her right to be free from torture and inhuman and degrading treatment and punishment under article 3 of the Convention and the right to respect for her private and family life under article 8.

Sheriff Court Hearing

The first court to consider a requested person’s extradition in Scotland is Edinburgh Sheriff Court. In that court, DV’s human rights-based arguments were dismissed. The state of prison conditions in Romania and the fact that DV was the mother of five children, with two residing with her, aged 19 and 12, were not such that her human rights could bar her extradition. As to article 8, the Sheriff noted that extradition would entail an interference with her family life but found that this would not be exceptionally severe for the family. The balance of factors firmly weighed in favour of extradition. DV then appealed to the High Court of Justiciary.

The Facts

Before the hearing at the High Court, lawyers for both DV and the Government of Romania agreed on a set of facts. Pre-eminent amongst them was that, after the evidence had been led at Edinburgh Sheriff Court, DV’s then 13-year-old daughter gave birth to a baby girl who also now lived in the family home. Further relevant information included DV’s significant parenting duties of both her grand-daughter and her daughter. The 13-year-old attended school, during which time DV cared for her grand-daughter. DV’s partner worked full time to support his family and as such was unable to provide parental support to the 13-year-old, his child, or to be the main carer of his child and grandchild.

No other family members had been identified by social workers as being able to provide care on a regular basis. A social care package was available to the 13-year-old, including a pastoral care teacher, social worker and nurse and financial benefits at the rate of £400 per month. A different but notable fact was that DV’s conviction in Romania was for the theft of food products.

The set of agreed facts also set out the consequences of DV’s extradition if her daughter remained in the UK or returned to Romania to live with her grandparents. Of particular note here was that if her daughter remained in the UK, she was likely to be taken into care. If she returned to Romania, she would receive support from her family there but would be removed from the support and education system available in Scotland, and from her (and her daughter’s) main care-giver.

The Arguments on Appeal

At the High Court of Justiciary, it was argued on behalf of DV that had the Sheriff taken into account the birth of her granddaughter, he would have decided the article 8 question differently. The human rights test he considered was firstly whether there would be an interference with article 8 rights, and if so, whether the gravity of the interference with family life was justified by the importance of the public interest pursed.  

The involvement of children has a real impact on human rights considerations. The law provides that a primary consideration in such cases are the interests of children. On behalf of DV, it was submitted that there was a strong public interest in ensuring that children are properly brought up. Both her child and grandchild would be taken into care if DV was extradited, her lawyer noted. As to the public interest, it was suggested that the offending in DV’s case was at the lowest end of the spectrum of criminal behaviour.

For the government of Romania, it was argued that in the balance between the human rights of DV, her child and grandchild, and the public interest in extradition, the latter prevailed. DV had a not-insubstantial criminal record in Romania and elsewhere. Whilst a ‘child should not be held responsible for the sins of her parent’ it should only be a very rare case that extradition is avoided. Given broadly similar circumstances within the UK, DV would have been imprisoned, notwithstanding the interests of dependent children.

The Decision

Lord Brodie, for the High Court, began by summarising the relevant law as being “… that there shall be no interference with a person’s right to respect for his family life such as in accordance with law and necessary for the prevention of disorder or crime” (para 26). He noted that it is inevitable than extradition will interfere with family life, akin to a sentence of imprisonment imposed by a domestic court. The case law is well-established. Inherent in the consideration of ‘necessary’ is a proportionality exercise. That usually leads to an extradition being justified. Lord Brodie noted that “the European Court of Human Rights has repeatedly said that it will only be in exceptional circumstances than an applicant’s private or family life in a contracting state will outweigh the legitimate aim pursued by his or her extradition” (para 27).

The law relating to the impact of children in the proceeding was then laid out. Not only was the effect of extradition on DV relevant. The family unit as a whole had to be considered, with each family member regarded as a potential victim (Norris v US [2010] 2 AC 487 para 64). Affected children’s interests were a primary consideration.

Framing consideration of the factors for and against extradition in an article 8 case are the rules set out in a leading English Divisional Court precedent Polish Judicial Authority v Celinski, 2015] EWHC 1274 (Admin). The approach to be adopted by UK courts is one which clearly sets out the facts and reasons for the conclusion arrived at by balancing the necessary conditions for and against extradition. In other words, a structured ‘balance sheet’ approach.

In adopting that method, Lord Brodie set out the factors in favour of and against returning DV to serve her sentence in Romania. He disputed one of the factors put forward by counsel for Romania, that being that the sentence of 13 months was ‘not insignificant’. He stated “What we have in the present case is a conviction for shoplifting of some items from a food store a number of years ago which attracted a custodial sentence of 13 months. If anything, the trivial nature of this offence points away from extradition…” (para 38). On the other hand, what were weighty factors in favour, he held, were the points that those convicted of crimes should serve their sentences and the UK should give effect to its treaty obligations.

Lord Brodie then held that it would not be proper in the circumstances to give effect to Romania’s extradition request. A primary interest for the court must be the interests of the children involved. Both DV’s child and grandchild were at risk of very serious detriment to their welfare. Withdrawing the childcare provided by DV, he stated, “would amount to an interference with the children’s article 8 rights in a way which will inevitably be damaging and probably very damaging” (para 40). “To imperil the chances of two children growing up into well-functioning adults by extraditing their primary carer at what are critical stages in their respective lives because of a conviction for shoplifting is, in our opinion, clearly disproportionate” (para 40). DV was discharged, and therefore free to continue with her life in Scotland.

Conclusion  

The application of human rights law normally entails a balance between the rights of the individual and broader societal interests, such as protecting society from disorder and crime. That balance is at the centre of DV’s case. Through the exceptional circumstance of a 13-year-old girl becoming a mother, together with the crime for which DV was to be sentenced being relatively minor, the human rights of DV and her family trumped the societal interest of adhering to extradition agreements and facilitating transnational criminal justice. Such balancing exercises are inherent in what are known as qualified human rights. These include the right to respect for private and family life, and freedom of expression and assembly and association.  Qualified human rights, and indeed all human rights, operate to particularly protect persons who, for one reason or the other, find themselves on the margins of society. They play a vital role in today’s society. They introduce a degree of humanity to the operation of the law and must be recognised as such and protected from ill-informed and unwarranted attacks.


Suggested citation: Arnell, Paul (2025) The Humanity of Human Rights, SLSS Research Blog (RGU), 2025/05. Available at: https://rgu-slss.blog/?p=2175

Author

Scroll to Top